Home Store Catering Awards, Articles & Videos Blog Pizza School Brick Ovens Location & Menu / Contact Us Inferno Order Online   
Best Pizza in New York, Best Pizza in the World

Creator of the Vodka Pie!

CLICK HERE
To join our VIP Club
and get a FREE DINNER
on your birthday!!!

pizza ovens for sale
Our Pizza Ovens are Certified by
the New York Brick Oven Co.




Best Pizza in the World - Winner New York Pizza Best Pizza in New York Goodfella's Restaurant in Staten Island Brick Oven Pizza, Brick ovens for sale
Best Pizza in New York
Best Pizza in New York




Welcome to The Original Goodfella’s Established 1992 at 1718 Hylan Blvd Staten Island Ny where it all started, home to the Best Pizza in New York and the World!

Since I was a little boy I always loved pizza. Growing up in Brooklyn having some of the best pizzas at places like Patsies, Toronto’s and all the other great family pizza places my love and passion for pizza began. My goal was to make nothing but the best pizza I could. With that goal in mind, and in our first year of business, I created the Vodka Pizza, a gourmet pizza unlike any other, that won me the prestigious honor of being Voted America's Best Pizza! At The Jacob Javits Center, New York City International Hotel and Restaurant show.

Throughout the years my staff and family have continued the tradition of creating our own gourmet pizzas that have won us many awards including the "World's Best Pizza" title Several times at the International Pizza Expo. We have also been featured on many TV stations in news papers, magazine articles as well as becoming a local hot spot for politicians, celebrities and local fans.

Today our tradition of quality still holds true. We use only the best ingredients to make our artisan pizza, like fresh mozzarella, imported San Marzano tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil and gourmet sauces cooked from scratch. We cook our pizzas with the old world tradition, in a real wood fired brick oven at 800 degrees that produces a flavor unlike any other.

We also offer great Italian food freshly prepared to order, a nice wine list with homemade sangria and a full bar menu as well.

We do private parties for any special occasion and take out catering for Staten Island, Brooklyn, and NYC. We even catered on the Presidential Yacht!

So if you’re looking for a great a place to go with friendly service a great staff and incredible food stop by today. We will always make you feel welcome.

Sincerely, Scot Cosentino and The Goodfella's Team

Italian Restaurant in Staten Island Staten Island Pizzeria Best Pizza in the World New York Catering, Presidential Yatch

Goodfella's catering the Presidential Yacht!!


Marc Cosentino of Goodfella's Pizza has written the first book about Staten Island's Finest and Routine Patrol in the 120 Precinct.


Click here to read all about it!



Marc from Expanding Marketing helped put us on the map since we opened our doors in 1992.